Management Matters with James-Christian Blockwood
Management Matters with James-Christian Blockwood brings together government and private sector leaders for in-depth conversations about the big issues impacting public service, government and more. A podcast of the National Academy of Public Administration.
Management Matters with James-Christian Blockwood
Guidance on Steps to Measure and Improve Organizational Health and Performance with John Kamensky
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode, we welcome John Kamensky, former chair of the Academy's Executive Organizational Management Standing Panel and Academy Fellow, to discuss the new OMB guidance on Organizational Health and Performance, the Academy's work in this area, and advice for agencies moving forward on this guidance.
Support the Podcast Today at:
donate@napawash.org or 202-347-3190
Music Credits: Sea Breeze by Vlad Gluschenko | https://soundcloud.com/vgl9
Music promoted by https://www.free-stock-music.com
Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/deed.en_
Part of this is not a compliance driven approach. It's sort of how do you create a campaign around improving organizational health and performance? Because this will improve trust in government. And so there needs to be a much more human element, a campaign element that's built into this for the implementation.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Management Matters, a National Academy of Public Administration podcast where policy meets practice. I'm Terry Girton, President of the Academy. The Federal Office of Management and Budget released new guidance to agencies last week on steps to measure and improve organizational health and performance. In this episode, I'll talk with John Kamensky about that memo and work he led with other Academy fellows nearly five years ago on the same topic. John has had a long federal career and now writes regularly on improving government performance, and he's a fellow of the National Academy of Public Administration. John, thanks so much for joining me today. Thanks so much for inviting me. Well, you know, um sometimes we say the wheels of government turn slowly, but with the perspective of time, sometimes we can look back and see what might have contributed to the change. So back in 2018, you led a group of Academy fellows in drafting a set of papers on how to strengthen organizational health and performance. It must be nice to see it circle back around into official documentation, but what prompted the effort five years ago?
SPEAKER_01There were a couple things that prompted that effort. One was that the NAPA standing panel on executive organization and management had been following this kind of an issue for many, many years. And we had this opportunity in 2018 at the request of one of the panel members, Dustin Brown, who is at the Office Management Budget, to explore the whole notion of being able to measure agency organizational health and performance since the Federal Employee Viewpoint Survey had been in operation for several years and created this amazing database of 24,000, I believe it was, operational units across the government that to assess uh employee engagement and other factors. And he said, is there some way that we can apply these kinds of data along with the data that had been developed under the Government Performance and Results Act to be able to assess how well agencies are doing?
SPEAKER_00And so when you started to look at that, I know one of the questions that the team dealt with back then was really defining organizational health and how you can measure it. So you had the federal employee viewpoint scores, but tell us a little bit more about how the team at that point defined organizational health.
SPEAKER_01Well, this is something that had actually been defined in the private sector uh uh for a number of years. And so, as a matter of how do you uh uh take this and make it relevant in the public sector. And there was a series of standards that had been developed over the years, uh, ISO 9000 standard, the European Common Assessment Framework, these were being applied in the private sector, the Baldridge criteria in the US, and a lot of these had elements that that paralleled what could be useful in a public sector setting. And so the question was: do you uh adopt a particular standard like Baldridge, or do you look at a process or a way of doing business? And that would be like Agile or TQM, Total Quality Management, uh, or you know, those kinds of approaches, uh, lean six sigma. And those have been used both in the public and private sector. And so what we did is we looked at what other countries were doing in this area and found that a number of countries had actually developed organizational capacity or organizational excellence uh uh approaches. Many of them were standards-based, some of them were process-based. The Canadian Management Accountability Frame, the Australian and the New Zealand Capability Review, the uh approach that was being used in India. So, what we did is is is one of some several of our panel members were also uh involved in private sector measures of organizational health. So, what we did is we sort of looked across all of these different approaches and didn't recommend a specific standard or specific process, but rather an overarching set of principles as to how to go about doing this. And so that's kind of where we came out. Now, organizational health, the an organization's ability to drive uh performance collectively in support of its mission and deliver programs and services. And this is something that is looking predominantly at the employees and the ability of mission support functions, uh HR, IT, contracting, grants management, those functions to be able to deliver on uh organizational programs. And these data can be are granular in nature and can be and are being measured uh across the government. The mission support function measures of something that's been going on for about a decade. Uh they've not been publicly released, but are used within agencies to compare and determine which things uh can be improved by looking at other people's processes. So there's a lot in the organizational health uh area that is fairly mature that could be used. And what we did is we looked at some specific agencies. We looked at the Department of Agriculture's approach to how they turned around uh lagging uh employee engagement scores. Uh, you gave us a case study of vets at the Department of Labor when you were there. The U.S. Army has an operational and organizational assessment system. I mean, theirs is enormous. They have 600 analysts uh that are in their operational research and systems analysis division. So there was a lot to draw on on that uh dimension.
SPEAKER_00And so the the premise, and it's sort of stating the obvious, I suppose, is that they help the organization with engaged employees do a better job of performing its mission. So, what really were some of the best practices that you noted in the papers that the panel put together?
SPEAKER_01Well, one of the things that that we were seeing uh there was that good customer service was often tied to uh engage high scores in employee engagement. And employee engagement, when you begin to break that down into some specifics, is the relationship between middle managers and their employees and the trust that employees have that the uh working environment that they are are in is fair and equitable. And the in the Office of Personnel Management surveys that's done every year, there are elements in there that can drive employees' perceptions of how well they're engaged in their work. And managers can if you break it down into like 24, 28,000 units, you can tell a manager this is something that you need to work on, and the middle managers, et cetera, that to improve. Uh and one of the the actual interesting drivers is the response rate to the employee survey. If the response rate is going up, that means that employees feel it's worth filling out because their managers are actually uh responding to concerns that were raised. And so that's a a key element uh in looking at organizational health, actually.
SPEAKER_00Well, and as I recall, about this time, OMB came out with its 2020-20 initiative, right? Which was to increase the scores of the bottom 20% of the FDVS agencies by 20% by 2020. Of course, 2020 happened to coincide with COVID, but was did you perceive that as being a positive response to the recommendations of the paper?
SPEAKER_01I don't know whether setting an arbitrary target such as 20% and by 2020, etc., is the appropriate. It sounds good and it does give upper level management something to focus on. But at the granular level, you really need to focus on, you know, whether in an air traffic control tower in Atlanta, whether the managers there are actually uh being supportive of their employees or whether they're short-staffed and overworked, et cetera. You can't control that with a 2020-20 type approach. But the the idea that senior level managers are committed to making a difference, I think is really important.
SPEAKER_00So as you've continued to watch this and write about it, and as we've experienced the global pandemic and really significant changes in how the federal government operates, what are you seeing in terms of the current measures of health in federal organizations?
SPEAKER_01Well, I thought it was interesting that when the pandemic struck, the federal agencies that had contingency plans already in place, that had practiced their work from home environments to make sure that their technology systems were robust enough that they were more prepared and that employees didn't skip a beat. In fact, there was uh early news that actually uh productivity went up for a number of agencies. And there was an IBM Center report that I worked on in uh 2020 looking at this, and agencies like the Patent and Trademark Office that already had a robust uh uh remote working environment didn't have any impact there. NASA was very good at transitioning. In fact, there's a story about how the scientists launched a satellite from home. Uh I mean there so there was some cool stuff, and the Department of Agriculture uh was and different parts of it uh were much more effective. Social Security Administration was slow to embrace telework, but once they did, their productivity increased. And if you begin comparing those agencies that were quick out of the box in the pandemic and compare them to the employee engagement scores uh that had preceded that, you sort of see a bit of a parallel that they're that the agencies that were ready to work in a telework environment already had uh better employee engagement scores for the most part.
SPEAKER_00So a little bit of a correlation there then to say that healthier organizations did tend to perform better through the pandemic. And so you can draw that correlation between organizational health and organizational performance.
SPEAKER_01Well, that requires some statistics, and I haven't run those yet, but I think that that sounds good. So let's stay with it.
SPEAKER_00We'll talk about uh correlation and not causality, I suppose. Well, so that kind of brings us up to the present day and this 19-page memo that OMB released last week, directing federal agencies with guidance on measuring, improving, and reporting on organizational health. What do you see as the key points in that memo?
SPEAKER_01Well, there were three major uh areas in that memo. And only the first area was picked up in the media, and that was the asking agencies to update their post-pandemic operational plans. There was a requirement during the pandemic that agencies develop operational plans of working uh from home versus working in an office, et cetera. And the guidance that came out stressed that agency workforces are generally expected to increase meaningful in-person work. So that was what was the headlines. But to me, that is a near-term impact of that memo. The longer-term impact were the other two parts of the memo. The second part directed agencies to establish ongoing routines to assess, monitor, progress, and diagnose issues related to organizational health and performance. It provided a definition of what OMB meant by organizational health and performance, which not that much different than what the uh NAPA study did. And then the third part was to develop uh an organizational health and performance framework. And that that there wasn't a framework imposed by OMB, but rather asking agencies to develop their own, because agencies have for different cultures. You're not going to have the same framework for the Patent and Trademark Office as you are for air traffic control or the Army Ordnance Uh Command and stuff like that. And to me, the the really insightful part of the guidance was that OMB asked agencies to develop as their unit of analysis, not the department for their performance framework, but rather major operating units. So in Treasury, for example, it's not going to be an organizational health and performance framework for Treasury. It's going to be an organizational health framework for the Mint, for the IRS, uh, for the fiscal service, with very different operating styles and missions. And so that makes those things, the frameworks, relevant in the context that employees are actually going to be working and in delivering their mission.
SPEAKER_00So that's a really different approach for OMB, who does oftentimes think that one size will fit everyone. So I guess we should be, you know, give them credit for that kind of positive approach. But it also makes it really challenging for an agency, then, who's got to think about all of those different cultures and organizations and missions and try to create frameworks that will accurately reflect but also motivate organizational help in those very different environments.
SPEAKER_01That's true. And what also was in the guidance that I thought was very insightful was that it's asking the performance improvement officers and the deputy secretaries or chief operating officers in the agencies and the departments to take the lead on this and to be the conveners. And they're to convene across mission support functions like uh the CFO, CIO, Chico, et cetera, to focus on what does it mean for organizational health in mission support functions, but also be the convener and creating communities of practice around the delivery units within agencies. So that would be veterans health or veterans cemetery or veterans benefits, et cetera. So the role of the performance improvement officers and the chief operating officers is kind of crucial to serve as conveners and not running uh an overarching framework. So it's going to be kind of bottom-up development of some of these uh uh frameworks, and it'll be interesting to see how different departments do it and how they begin sharing across departments through these communities of practice that are being encouraged. Now, interestingly, the NAPA study was done in 2018. There was a similar study on measuring organizational quality uh done by the IBM Center in 2020, and it had been and it convened many of the same people that were involved in the NAPA study. And then there was a subsequent, like ad hoc group that was brought together in 2021 to support a presidential transition that built on both the NAPA and the IBM Center studies, and that study focused on creating these communities of practice. So the OMB guidance actually drew on all three of these different reports to come up with a guidance, or at least that's my correlation. And so I was very encouraged by it. The challenge, and I think is that's going to be the big thing, is what's the next step and who's in charge. The the guidance talks about the uh role of the President's Management Council, which is the deputy secretaries and chief operating officers of all the major departments and agencies as being uh an important element in driving the overall implementation on this.
SPEAKER_00I think what I hear you saying is with all of the work that's been done in this space by government-adjacent organizations and all of the work that's been done in the private sector, the performance improvement officers and others that are gonna be charged with this, they aren't starting from a blank sheet of paper, but there's a pretty aggressive timeline here. How do you think they're gonna be able to pull all of this together within the timelines that they've set in this memo?
SPEAKER_01And that's a good question. I think part of it is that it's gonna, I don't know right now who is going to be like the program management officer for orchestrating this out of either OMB or GSA or uh a group uh convened by the President's Management Council. I'm just not uh privy to that. But there's a lot of support that I think that whoever begins the convening will get from outside groups. The Partnership for Public Service, the National Academy, the IBM Center, uh the Volcker Alliance, um, I think MITRE might have a role. So there are a lot of, I think, organizations that want to be helpful, um, that uh have a history in trying to support improved organizational health and performance.
SPEAKER_00So that's good. And of course, NAPA wants to be part of that support as well. But as you think about the lack of clarity about who's really in charge, the density of the requirements that are in this memo, the timeline, some of the initial responses seem to suggest that this might become just one more compliance exercise. So, how do you think agencies get away from just checking the box and turning in their homework on time to really making this part of a culture change as they try to implement these directions?
SPEAKER_01That's a very good question. I don't know what OMB's thinking is on this at this point. They there's a lot of data, there's a lot of material to work from. And the question is, how is it orchestrated? Now, if I look back to 30 years ago when the the national performance review or the reinventing government initiative was we developed a report in six months, and I had been at the time uh from the uh government accountability office, and I was looking at compliance, because that was you know from GAO, and I was looking at the thousand or so recommendations that came out and was trying to create like a spreadsheet that fracked the implementation of all the recommendations. And Bob Stone, who was the career lead for the overall initiative, says, Oh, Comadsky, don't deal with that. Focus instead on successes. I said, But Bob, the recommendations haven't been implemented. He said, Oh, you just don't understand. This stuff is actually going on out in the agencies, and what we need to do is go out and find them and showcase them and show other people that you can do this yourself. You don't have to rely on the headquarters or stuff. And that led to the creation of reinvention labs, re- the recognition awards, what were called hammer awards. And I was just laughing. He had one of the fellows that worked on the team get on his motorcycle and drive around the country to different federal agencies uh across the country, looking for success elements that reflected what was going on, what the principles of the reinventing government, putting customers first or cutting red tape, or empowering employees and identifying them and showcasing them back in Washington with example as examples that you can do this. And so part of this is not a compliance uh-driven approach. It's sort of how do you create a campaign around improving organizational health and performance? Because this will improve trust in government. And so there there needs to be a much more human element, a campaign element that's built into this for the implementation. And that's something that I can envision something like the president. Management counselor, someplace like that, engaging with uh nonprofit groups, like the Evidence Act was highly promoted by the uh Data Foundation and Results for America and set as a way of it wasn't just a compliance effort, but it was a how do we use evidence to drive decisions? So part of this is is is going to be um different than the traditional OMB memo. And I'm looking to see how that might happen.
SPEAKER_00That's a really interesting example, storytelling and and finding folks who are already doing this and using them to motivate the other organizations to take action. But as you think about storytelling, and you mentioned the Partnership for Public Service earlier, they annually published the best places to work, and they just recently released the latest version. But that showed a downward trend in many of the responses. So what do you take from that? What should organizational leaders take from this latest round of reporting on the Federal Employee Viewpoint Survey, which came out just about the same time as this guidance to improve organizational health and performance?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, one of the things that I found interesting about the Federal Employee Viewpoint Survey is they will tell you what, but they won't tell you why, because they don't have open-ended questions. When I was involved with the reinventing government initiative, we were using some of OPM's earlier version of the Federal Employee Viewpoint Survey and just a subset of questions, about 30 as opposed to the hundred that they use. And but we had an open-ended section of it. And the Office of Personnel Management says, oh, the open-ended stuff is not very useful. We found the open-ended stuff was where the richness and the understanding why people were responding the way they were. And so the survey kind of misses that right now. So the the we don't know why, but there can be assumptions that are made. One of the things is that there's a lead lag uh among the indicators in uh a lot of surveys, so that the way people felt a year ago may reflect the way you respond today, but the world is actually different today, or the world today is different than it used to be. So, so you don't quite know. I know that in the private sector that you can predict profit by customer satisfaction, which in turn can be predicted by employee satisfaction. And so there's this actual causality uh that you can predict in the private sector, but it's over like a period of 18 months. So I don't know what that might translate to in a public sector uh environment, but also in the public sector, you're dealing with politics and budget variations as well as managers, et cetera. So it's it's a lot more complicated. Uh so but I I know I I was also uh surprised to see that the indicators are were decreasing, but I don't have a uh but I think in part this guidance is a response to that, saying we know there's a problem, we need to pay more attention to it, because until we can get a handle on this, citizens are not going to increase their trust in government, which is uh at a low point.
SPEAKER_00Well, and I just want to pick up on a connection that you made in that last response, which was employee experience, customer experience, and organizational performance. So this organizational health and performance memo and the guidance associated with it seems to link very clearly, although not explicitly, to the uh the president's management agenda's focus on customer experience and building trust in government. Can you say a little bit about where you think that's headed?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and that that was something that the reinventing government initiative back in the 90s was focused on is uh how do you improve citizen trust in government? And at the time it was focusing on customer service. And today, customer experience, which is a much more nuanced and sophisticated approach because it looks at the full experience and the interaction of different services across government, not just a specific service like receiving a check in the mail or something like that. And so being able to leverage this better understanding and ways of how do you use this to improve citizen trust in government is something that I think we're gonna continue to grapple with, and that this organizational health and performance approach, if it's goes beyond a memo to actually we're gonna try to change the government culture, uh, is going to be a I think a key element of being able to do that.
SPEAKER_00So when I think about the evolution that led to this memo, I'm kind of looking back five years and thinking that's radical uh speed for the federal government to kind of move forward on something. But now, as you look forward, what gives you hope in this space? You've been watching organizational health and performance for a long time. Do you see this as moving towards institutionalization of this attention to organizational health and performance?
SPEAKER_01Yes. And in fact, Don Moynihan, who is also a uh NAPA fellow uh and a very accomplished author, has written about this and says new administrative routines such as the organizational health uh framework turn into culture eventually. And so by beginning a routine now which may feel formulaic, you will ultimately change the way people work. And and I thought that was kind of an interesting approach, I because I've been waiting for the culture to change for uh performance and the Government Performance and Results Act. And what the late fellow Harry Hatry was saying is what we need to do is move this down into the agencies. You can't leave it at the headquarters level. And so that's what this memo is doing is it's pushing the uh uh paying attention to organizational health and performance down into the operating units. And that's where I think change will happen.
SPEAKER_00I love that. So if you want to change the culture, change the rules, right? And then watch.
SPEAKER_01But the key, yeah, the key is uh commitment to implementation, and this is going to be a long-term thing. It's not something that's just issuing a memo and saying in 90 days or 150 days, uh, submit this plan or that plan.
SPEAKER_00So as we watch presidential management agendas and the implementation of those, you're recommending a watch and monitor and um hopefully celebrate success as we move down this path. Yes. Thank you. Well, John, thanks so much for joining us today. I I really am grateful for the work that you led five years ago. I really think we were sort of there at the creation, if you will, of the move towards measurement of organizational health and performance. And I'm delighted to see this latest manifestation. So thanks for joining us today. Thank you. The Academy's Spring Appeal is here, and your support of the Academy directly supports our work towards ensuring a just, fair, and inclusive government that strengthens communities and protects democracy. You can show your support for our mission by visiting the links to our website located in the show notes.