Management Matters with James-Christian Blockwood
Management Matters with James-Christian Blockwood brings together government and private sector leaders for in-depth conversations about the big issues impacting public service, government and more. A podcast of the National Academy of Public Administration.
Management Matters with James-Christian Blockwood
200th Episode!!! The Future of the Academy with Janet Weiss
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode, we welcome Janet Weiss, Chair of the Academy's Board and Academy Fellow, to discuss the future of the Academy.
Support the Podcast Today at:
donate@napawash.org or 202-347-3190
Music Credits: Sea Breeze by Vlad Gluschenko | https://soundcloud.com/vgl9
Music promoted by https://www.free-stock-music.com
Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/deed.en_
Welcome to Management Matters, the award-winning National Academy of Public Administration podcast where policy meets practice. I'm Terry Gurden, President of the Academy. Seems hard to believe, but this is our 200th podcast episode. Over the course of nearly four years, I've had the chance to talk about the Academy's grand challenges, highlighted amazing stories in public administration through conversations with many of our Academy fellows. And to celebrate this amazing series in today's episode, I'll chat with Academy Fellow Janet Weiss. Janet is on the Management and Organizations faculty of the Ross School of Business and the Ford School of Public Policy at the University of Michigan. And she chairs the Academy's Board of Directors. We'll talk about her vision for the Academy and its role in the field of public administration. Janet, thanks so much for joining me today to celebrate our 200th episode. Thank you for inviting me. Very happy to be here. Well, I always like to start with our guest's own story. What inspired you to take up the work of public administration?
SPEAKER_01When I was in college and a graduate student, I fell in love with the research and decided to pursue a PhD in social psychology. But it was a politically tumultuous time. It was the late 60s and early 70s. I was personally engaged in student protest against the war in Vietnam, in support of civil rights and gender equality. And probably because of that, I became very intellectually interested in the question of how psychological research could be used to make better public policy. I thought we were urgently in need of better public policy. But the more I studied that, I learned to my dismay that good ideas about public policy often crashed on the rocks of implementation. And even well-implemented public policies didn't necessarily work the way they were intended when you went back and evaluated them. And the more I wanted to learn about, well, so why is that? I discovered that what in my first naive impression was, well, government agencies were just doing a bad job of implementing this wise public policy that had been informed by research and adopted by policymakers. I learned instead that it was the product of some systematic features of public administration that both intentionally and unintentionally made it difficult to implement policy. And these are things that our listeners will be very familiar with: the importance of transparency, the importance of procedural fairness, the importance of accountability, fiscal prudence, et cetera, et cetera. So I realized that I had to understand those in order to understand how to design more effective policy and get better outcomes. So without ever expecting or planning it, I ended up in public administration.
SPEAKER_00That is an amazing story. And I can only imagine as you're on campus today that you're feeling some parallels between the start of your own career and what students are dealing with today. What do you find most encouraging and maybe most challenging as you work with the students who will be the next generation of public administrators and leaders?
SPEAKER_01Well, I have always taught graduate students, both in public policy and business. So I haven't had a lot of direct exposure to undergraduate students. But my graduate students are a little older. They've come back to school after usually some graduating from college and then some years of work experience. So what's wonderful about them is their energy, their enthusiasm, their ambition to really have an impact. And yes, today on our campus is graduation day. And uh so the campus is full of happy students and tremendously proud families who are here to celebrate their accomplishments. But of course, we also have protests because we are the University of Michigan. We believe in protest, we allow and support protest, and it is a time when a lot of students have a lot on their minds. So what gives me hope is that the students I come in contact with are incredibly dedicated to having an impact in the world, either through business or through public policy, to see the ways that they're the expertise that they have gotten in graduate school, how that is gonna make it possible for them to improve the future.
SPEAKER_00It's gotta be encouraging to be in that environment of energy and optimism on a daily basis. Well, you and I both became fellows in the same year in 2017. I'm curious to know what you knew about the Academy then, when you said yes to being a fellow and what you expected it to entail.
SPEAKER_01When I first became a fellow, I really knew very little. Uh, I think I'm probably pretty typical in that regard. I really knew about the honorific role of the academy in recognizing distinguished accomplishment. And about the same time I became a fellow, my husband was elected as a fellow of the National Academy of Science. And I knew about the honorific role of the National Academy of Science and the role that that played. So I was excited about the possibility of joining for the honor of belonging to this company of uh such accomplished people.
SPEAKER_00And yet we made you work.
SPEAKER_01Well, and and that's a good thing because at the time I joined, I had had a couple of sustained collaborations with public administration practitioners, which I had very much enjoyed. And I thought of joining the academy as an opportunity to learn more and to work more frequently with practitioners. And that, in fact, has been the case and a source of great pleasure for me.
SPEAKER_00Well, I'm so impressed that you so quickly jumped into not only the opportunities that we give fellows to participate in panels and you know, study groups, but you volunteered to join the board, and then you chaired the governance committee for a couple of years, and now you're the chair of the board of directors. Why did you want to take on that role?
SPEAKER_01Well, one of the things that I did during my academic career was I started, and this is now 25 years ago, so quite a while, I started a program at the University of Michigan for nonprofit board governance. And so for the last 25 years, uh off and on, I have been working with many hundreds of students and about 300 nonprofit organizations across Michigan. We place our graduate students on as non-voting members of boards of nonprofit agencies. And we work with those boards over the course of an academic year. And I offer training to students and to boards about what effective board governance looks like. And I've served on a number of boards myself, including before I joined the Academy Board, a service on a couple, two other professional association boards. So it seemed like a natural to me once I realized that the Academy was a place where really good work happened and it was worth investing in. So I saw service on the board and especially on the governance committee as a way of giving back to Napa and helping to ensure that good things would continue to happen there.
SPEAKER_00Well, you really brought best practices to us, certainly based on your expertise. And so why did you want to stop leading the governance committee and lead the whole board?
SPEAKER_01Well, once I joined the board, I realized, as any board member listening to this will know, that the board is a terrific group of people. Uh, we bring an extremely diverse set of experiences and perspectives to our common goal of supporting NAPA. And we get along very well. And so it is really a pleasure to work with a group of people who are both so accomplished and so willing to work together for some common goals. I was happy to agree when someone suggested to me that I do this.
SPEAKER_00Well, I consider myself very fortunate to have worked with a fabulous board over my tenure, um, and now to serve with you as the board chair. Um, as you say, the the mix of expertise is just astonishing, but the commitment to the well-being of the organization is so palpable that NAPA wouldn't be who it is without the board providing that kind of guidance and leadership. So I'm very grateful. Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Well, thank you for thank you for saying so. Uh, we of course feel right back at you, Terry. Um we have all of us been tremendously impressed with your leadership as president of the academy. And now that you have decided that it's time for you to move on to something else in your life, our current priority, of course, is organizing a search for a new CEO. And that has led all of us to a lot of conversation about the future of the Academy as we think about, you know, who is the right kind of person to move into a leadership position at the Academy. So I am really interested in your perspective. You have a kind of unique vantage point on the work of the Academy. So, what do you see as the most exciting opportunities for the Academy over the next few years?
SPEAKER_00That is such a great question because there's so many things we could talk about, and we don't have nearly the amount of time, but I thought, you know, I am really excited about the progress we're making in our grand challenges in public administration. You know, we're just about halfway through what we envision to be a decade-long effort, and COVID slowed us down for a couple of years. Maybe we'll have to add a couple of years onto the back of it, but we're really now seeing traction, especially in local governments, as they use the grand challenges to inform how they think strategically and tactically about how they serve their neighbors. And we've got a network of associations and local leaders, the local government 2030 team are who are developing practical programs to advance these concepts. And we've seen them reflected in the at the federal level in the president's management agenda. So, you know, when we started Grand Challenges in 2019, we weren't quite sure where it would go. We knew it was the right thing to do, but I'm really excited now about the traction we see. And as we get it rolling, more people engaging in the grand challenges. I'm also very excited to see the synergy that's growing between our strategic initiatives and our agency studies. It was always the vision as we stood up the strategic initiatives team, but now it's happening all the time. As an example, our work on agile government is now informing some of the recommendations we make to agencies through our studies as they consider how to better serve their customers. And the research we're doing on organizational health and performance incorporates the agile government methods and hopefully will help address some of the issues we see with public trust in government. And the lessons we're learning as we engage deeply with government agencies, is coming back now to inform and advance our own research. So we've always hoped that those two things would work together, and now they are. They're feeding each other and growing in a really exciting way. And I do think the other thing that I would just have to highlight here, and it's really a function of this of the strategic plan that we put in place in 2022, is the way that the Academy's begun to build networks of partnerships with other good government groups that are integrating what had been separate and sometimes competitive programs. Because we're finding that as we all bring our best initiatives around public governance and administration to the table, there's a lot more power and leverage and reach when we work together. And I think that's going to be absolutely essential over the next few years as the market for people's attention becomes more and more fragmented. So it's going to take all of us together and through our own organizational networks to really communicate common messages about the importance of good government and how to deliver it. So those are the kinds of nerdy things that get me excited about the Academy's work. But let me ask you the same question, Janet. As the board chair, what do you see as the most exciting opportunities? And what do you think are going to be the biggest challenges in the coming year?
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm happy to meet you at the nerdiest possible level. I really am excited about all the everything that you mentioned. I think the Grand Challenges work really gives us a platform for engaging a lot of our fellows in coming together, uh, sharing expertise and interacting with all of our stakeholder communities in in ways that have a tremendous amount of potential. And I'm very excited to see those move forward. You know, you asked me earlier about what I knew about the academy at the time I joined. I really didn't understand at the time I joined how much of the academy's work was dedicated to doing studies for agencies, particularly federal agencies, that kind of service to the federal government, which grows out of our original federal charter and has been uh, you know, over the long history of the Academy, has been one of our major contributions, that that really takes up a lot of the time and energy and and intellectual bandwidth of the Academy staff. What's really exciting now is to see that work continue to grow and to flourish, and then to be joined by the work that is being done around the Grand Challenges and other strategic initiatives. So, not just to be reactive to the questions that were being asked by other people, but to be able to put questions on the table ourselves and to put answers on the table ourselves so that that conversation can spread through our networks of stakeholders. And I guess that points me to what I see as a major challenge for us going forward, which is in light of the current budget, I'm not sure what the right word is to use, you know, blockage. Uh at the federal level, it's kind of a vulnerable position to be too dependent on discretionary federal funding. And many of our studies are requested by Congress, but not very many of them are directly funded by Congress. So it is, you know, there are some financial risks to the Academy going forward if the federal budget doesn't sort of find its way to a more functional mode of uh of operating. And you know, many, many, many people, you know, we are only a tiny little small example of why this is a challenge, but many, many people uh hope for that um in the coming years. And you also flag something else that I think is really a challenge, which is on the one hand, the the decline in public trust in government. And then on the other hand, a kind of very surprising and disturbing political polarization around questions of that have been bipartisan, non-partisan throughout my entire professional career, which is the idea that government should operate efficiently and effectively. Somehow this has become up for partisan debate. And I that's that's a very troubling development in my mind. In my mind, the huge strength of the Academy is that it is nonpartisan, it doesn't take a partisan position. It is not only about serving the interests of one party or the other. It is really dedicated to ensuring that whatever the elected officials decide to pursue, that we have a set of institutions that can carry out those objectives in a way that is both efficient and effective, and that we have the data and the evidence to be able to know that that's true. So I think things that we've been able to take for granted that there would be political support for these issues have become more uncertain. And I think that's an important challenge for us going forward.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I would agree with you absolutely. Those are the two biggest challenges I think we face. And then I always try to frame my own perspective on this as challenges are just opportunities in disguise, right? So when we think about resourcing, you're absolutely right in that we rely to a large extent on federal funding for a variety of our projects. But as a nonprofit, we depend on donors to augment the revenue that we generate from our study contracts. And that market is becoming more and more fragmented as well. And we're not a frontline program service delivery organization, which is where a lot of philanthropy flows. So making our case for sustainment funding as the leader of the field of public administration for the long term is so important. It's really challenging for us, but I think it's also an opportunity. And the same on the issues of polarization, because we sort of mentioned earlier breaking through a fragmented communications market. And that's going to continue. As you said, we see topics that really used to be universally accepted good government precepts like fairness and equity and access and neutrality being challenged through partisan language. And we are, by charter, a nonpartisan organization that champions that effective public management to meet the Academy's vision, which I just have to say here: just, fair, and inclusive government that supports communities and protects democracy. So we're going to have to be even more creative in articulating and defending our principles in that nonpartisan spirit. I could not agree with you more.
SPEAKER_01And let me just add a couple of other quick challenges, which are again also opportunities that are embedded in some of what you just said. So one is as technology changes, both technology in the way the academy operates and the way the The Academy interacts with our fellows, and the way the Academy interacts with all of our stakeholders trying to get our message out, working with partners and collaborators, working with public administrators around the country, even around the world, being able to understand both the opportunities and the risks that those technical advances provide for us, I think, is a key challenge going forward. And then the second one that I would point to is embedded in the mission of the academy, is as you just described it, which is the critical importance of diversity, equity, inclusion, and access in our work. And that affects us at all levels, you know, in inside the staff of the academy, inside the board of the academy, in the selection of our fellows, in the relationships among our fellows, in the organization of our standing panels, in the kinds of contracts that we work on, and the kind of expertise that we need in order to carry out those contracts. And in the messages that we put out into the world of public administration about why it is that diversity, equity, inclusion, and access are so fundamental to the effectiveness of government at all levels. So these are things that we've been working hard on in recent years, and yet there is so much more to do. You're absolutely right.
SPEAKER_00I heard a great story the other day about the application of AI to government program delivery because when agencies have to put up websites, you know, they might get, they'll definitely get it out in English, they might get it out in Spanish, right? They might have a third language. But uh this was from the US Department of Labor's CIO who said AI will let me put it out there in thousands of languages to open up access to everybody, right? If we're going to provide employment opportunities across the country, why not just apply AI to translate your website into whatever language? And I thought, yes, yes, technology and accessibility. We can do this. That's a wonderful story. So, Janet, you know, as we think forward, what's your vision for the future? We're a small organization with a big mission. Where do we get the resources? How do we pull all of this together and pull it off?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think the history of the academy would tell us that there is no one vision for the Academy. The Academy is a kind of serendipitous collision of lots of different visions that that come to us from groups of fellows and from our history and and from our stakeholders. So I would not be, I would not be so presumptuous to to be able to articulate any any one mission. I think the strategic plan that we do uh that we did adopt a couple of years ago sets us up very well. We're finding our way to productive uh avenues, ways of making strategic investments in the time and energy of the Academy and our fellows that will allow us to continue to work from a position of strength to offer uh opportunities for the future. One of the most important ways, maybe, in which I see that happening in the next few years is increased engagement with state and local partners. That the academy has had a kind of DC-heavy presence, and there are more fellows, for example, in the DC area than anywhere else in the country. On the other hand, we do have fellows all over the country and we have fellows abroad. And I think we are poised at this point in our institutional history to be able to do much more at that level, and I think that's very exciting. So, one of the things that we teach in business school is that if you want to be successful at raising money for investment from donors or investors, one of the most important things you have to do is differentiate yourself from other people who are offering the same services that you are. And so I am interested in your sense of how the academy is different from other groups, especially who are working at the national level, other groups who are working on behalf of good government.
SPEAKER_00I give this elevator speech all the time. So I'm happy to add it into the podcast here. Our congressional charter is the place I always start. That makes us very unique. We are one of only two congressionally chartered national academies. You mentioned the National Academies of Science earlier. We're the only organization in the good government space that has a charter and a mission that's written into law by the Congress. So that's one. We have nearly a thousand amazing elected academy fellows who are the core of our expertise aspect of government federal, state, local, academic, they're practitioners, they're teachers, they're accomplished. And it's a stable of expertise that we bring to every piece of our work. And no one else has that collection of expertise. And then I would say we're a three-part organization, which is kind of different. We're part membership organization. We have to take care of those thousand fellows. We're part consultancy and digging in deep with agency partners to solve particular problems, and we're part think tank. So we're a little bit of all of that, but really it's our unique ability to conduct analysis and make systematic recommendations that both recognize and consider our entire federated system of government that's then integrated with the most current and reputable academic research, so we can present comprehensive and holistic solution sets to our stakeholders.
SPEAKER_01And we are only on the sixth floor.
SPEAKER_00It's a slow elevator.
SPEAKER_01That was great. And I think we do need to keep making that case for ourselves if we are going to stand out in a way that that will allow us to have the kind of broad-based broad-based impact that I can make one other distinction though, because a lot of people will ask us, well, how are you different from GAO as an example?
SPEAKER_00Don't they do the same kind of research? And we always say, what's different about us is that our work uniquely blends theory and practice so that our clients and our stakeholders take away not only a thorough understanding and diagnosis of their challenges, which is often where GAO does really well but stops. But we also provide recommendations and implementation plans to address those challenges so that organizations can make change and progress. So that's important to what we leave behind with organizations. But at the federal level, it's also really important to members of Congress and staffers who have to provide oversight of those agencies because these reports not only give them a diagnosis, but also a treatment plan. And that's something that's really unique to NAPA.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's very helpful. So, Terry, as you look forward to your departure at the end of this year, what are your hopes for what happens at the Academy in its next chapter?
SPEAKER_00I'm really delighted that I get to stay on as a fellow, first of all, so I can stay involved, although I won't have to be in charge after December. But I think, you know, when I think about that, two things. One, I want the Academy to last, right? I absolutely believe that it's an essential organization, that it's uniquely positioned to lead in a nonpartisan way that can help government at all levels adapt to these massive challenges we've been talking about, so that it can secure and deliver government programs for the future. There just is no one else that does what we do. So I want it to last and I want it to grow. I mean, the demand for what we do is growing. Every day I take calls and emails from somebody asking us to engage in a new project or convene a new group or you know, bring fellows to a discussion. And right now, we just don't have the capacity to say yes to all of those important requests. So we need to find ways to grow without losing sight of our core mission. So those are the two things I hope for whoever comes next. But Janet, uh, likewise a question for you. Because if at the end of the day, I and I know I learned this in business school, when you're leaving, you always want to leave a note in your desk for your successor, right? So you're not leaving the board just yet, but if you were going to leave a note in the drawer for the next academy president, what would you want to tell that person?
SPEAKER_01I would want to tell that person that you you have something precious and valuable here. So number one, don't screw it up. And number two, always be thinking about ways to carefully, thoughtfully, and strategically, but always in the spirit of moving forward. That there are so many opportunities for the expertise uh within the academy to be helpful in a wide variety of venues and and to be helpful in a way where we are constantly learning, we at the academy are constantly learning, as well as the public administrators with whom you're interacting are constantly learning. And as we all learn together to have the optimism and the persistence and the dedication to keep us moving forward. And I am very hopeful uh that that we will find somebody um who will help us to do this. You have left us with very large shoes to fill. We are all incredibly grateful to you, Terry, for how much better off the Academy is today than it was when you joined. And how much stronger it is on so many dimensions. And you and your team of really talented and hardworking people have helped to make it so. And because we are now in a good position, I believe that that we will uh be able to find somebody who will help us to move forward.
SPEAKER_00Well, thank you, Janet. Thanks for that. The one note I'd leave to the person who comes after me would be to take great care of that staff and the fellows, because they are the the juice behind what we do. And so, like you, I'm anxious as the process moves forward that we find the right person, but I'm sure we will. So thanks for joining me on the podcast today. This has been a fun conversation and a great way to celebrate 200 episodes. Thanks, Janet.
SPEAKER_01Well, congratulations to you on your 200th episode, and I look forward to what comes next.
SPEAKER_00Thanks. For our listeners, check back every Monday for a new episode from the Academy as we work to build a just, fair, and inclusive government that strengthens communities and protects democracy.